Substack vs. Medium

Substack vs Medium: compare newsletters, audience discovery, paid subscriptions, publications, monetization, community, and which platform is better for writers

November 17, 2026

Khang Nguyen · Operations Specialist

Substack vs. Medium

Substack and Medium both help writers publish online and reach readers, but they reward very different strategies.

Substack is built around owning a subscriber relationship. Writers publish posts, newsletters, podcasts, video, and community updates while growing an email list that can later become a paid subscription business.

Medium is built around publishing into an existing reading network. Writers can publish to their profile or to larger publications, and Medium distributes stories through recommendations, topics, publications, search, and its member ecosystem.

Quick answer

Choose Substack if you want to build a direct email audience, monetize with paid subscriptions, publish multiple content formats, and develop a long-term creator business around subscribers.

Choose Medium if your priority is writing and discovery, especially if you want to reach readers already browsing Medium without first building an email list.

Substack is usually better for audience ownership and recurring subscription revenue. Medium is often better for writers who want built-in readership and a lower-maintenance publishing environment.

Substack vs. Medium at a glance

FeatureSubstackMedium
Best forNewsletter-led creator businessesWriting and reader discovery
Email listCore productNot the center of the platform
Paid monetizationPaid subscriptionsPartner Program based on member engagement
Reader networkRecommendations, Notes, app discoveryMedium feed, publications, topics, Boost
PublicationsIndividual or multi-author publicationsProfiles and editorial publications
CommunityComments, Notes, Chat, direct subscriber relationshipsReplies, highlights, claps, follows
MultimediaText, podcast, video, live videoPrimarily article publishing
Pricing modelFree to publish; 10% platform fee on paid subscriptionsFree to publish; writers can earn through Partner Program

1. Audience ownership: Substack has the stronger direct relationship

The biggest difference is what happens after someone becomes a reader.

On Substack, a subscriber joins your email list. Your newsletter can reach them directly in their inbox, and your subscriber relationship remains central even if they rarely open the Substack app.

Substack also lets creators export subscriber data, making the email list a valuable long-term business asset.

Medium works differently.

Readers follow writers, publications, and topics inside Medium. Distribution is strongly connected to Medium's own recommendation system and membership network.

That can be powerful for discovery, but the relationship is more platform-centric.

Winner: Substack

If you want to build an audience you can contact directly through email, Substack has the clearer advantage.

2. Discovery: Medium makes it easier to publish into an existing reading network

Medium's greatest strength is that readers already visit the platform specifically to read.

Stories can be distributed through followers, topics, recommendations, publications, search engines, and Boost.

Writers can also submit stories to publications, which function like magazines with their own editors, audiences, and editorial identity.

Substack has invested heavily in discovery too. Recommendations, Notes, trending topics, collaborations, and the Substack app can introduce creators to new readers. Substack says more than half of new subscriptions now come from its network.

The difference is the unit of growth.

Medium is optimized around discovering stories and writers.

Substack is optimized around discovering creators and converting readers into subscribers.

3. Monetization: subscriptions vs. engagement-based earnings

Substack has a straightforward paid-subscription model.

Publishing is free. If a creator turns on paid subscriptions, Substack currently takes 10% of subscription revenue, plus payment-processing fees handled through Stripe.

Creators decide what is free, what is paid, and how much subscribers pay.

Medium's Partner Program works differently.

Eligible writers can earn based on how Medium members engage with their stories. Medium considers signals such as reading time, claps, highlights, replies, follows, and Boost distribution.

That means writers do not need to convince each reader to buy an individual newsletter subscription.

Which model is better?

Choose Substack if you want predictable recurring revenue from a loyal audience.

Choose Medium if you prefer to earn from reader engagement inside a larger membership ecosystem.

4. Publishing format: Substack is broader

Medium is excellent for written articles.

Its clean editor and reading experience are deliberately focused on text-based publishing.

Substack has expanded into a broader creator platform. A publication can now include:

  • long-form posts;
  • newsletters;
  • podcasts;
  • video posts;
  • live video;
  • comments;
  • subscriber chats;
  • Notes;
  • paid and free content.

Substack's video tools can also generate transcripts and distribute audio into podcast feeds.

Winner: Substack

For creators building a multimedia publication rather than only an article archive, Substack offers more native formats.

5. Community

Medium's community interactions are centered around writing. Readers can clap, highlight passages, reply, follow writers, and participate through publications.

Substack's community layer is broader and more subscriber-oriented.

Creators can use comments, Notes, chats, live video, and subscriber-only content to create a recurring relationship around the publication.

For a writer who wants to operate more like an independent media brand or membership community, this can matter.

6. SEO and long-term publishing

Both platforms can rank in search engines, but neither offers the same degree of control as a full CMS such as WordPress or Ghost.

Medium benefits from a large, established domain and publication ecosystem. That can help individual stories gain visibility.

Substack gives creators a dedicated publication site and supports custom domains, although creators still operate within Substack's publishing system.

If your primary goal is complete technical SEO control, neither is the most flexible option.

If your primary goal is publishing quickly without managing infrastructure, both are excellent.

Which should you choose?

Choose Substack if you:

  • want to grow an email list;
  • plan to sell paid subscriptions;
  • publish podcasts or video alongside writing;
  • want direct subscriber relationships;
  • care about creator-to-creator recommendations;
  • want community features around a publication.

Choose Medium if you:

  • primarily write articles;
  • want access to an existing reading audience;
  • prefer not to manage a newsletter business;
  • want to publish through established Medium publications;
  • like engagement-based monetization;
  • value a distraction-free writing and reading environment.

Use Substack and Medium together with WebCatalog

Many writers use both platforms strategically.

A creator might publish the main newsletter on Substack while republishing selected essays on Medium to reach new readers.

With WebCatalog Desktop, you can run Substack and Medium as dedicated desktop apps rather than mixing publishing dashboards with normal browser tabs.

WebCatalog Profiles also help writers keep personal, client, and brand accounts separate.

Using Spaces, a Writing Space could include:

  • Substack
  • Medium
  • Google Docs
  • Grammarly
  • Canva
  • analytics tools

Substack vs. Medium: final verdict

Substack is the stronger choice for writers who want to build a direct audience, grow an email list, and monetize through subscriptions.

Medium is the stronger choice for writers who want article discovery inside an established reading network and prefer monetization tied to member engagement.

For creators who want both audience ownership and broader distribution, using both can make sense - and WebCatalog can keep the two publishing workflows organized in separate desktop apps.

Related articles

Related apps